Give Jennifer Miller a Call: 305-240-0592
All these places can hook you up with Off Shore, Inshore, Snorkeling and sight seeing
Bud N Mary's marina has multiple charter boats and can set you up with anything you want and has a small bkfst. grill you can grab food before the charters but they stopped doing splits, (teaming you up with small groups) They also have a nice little store to get souvenir T-Shirts and hats.
Holiday Isle 305-433-9941 http://www.holidayisle.com/islamorada-fishing
Whale Harbor Marina 305-664-4511 http://whaleharbormarina.com/
Robbies 305-664-8070 http://robbies.com/ Postcard Inn & Marina https://www.holidayisle.com/florida-keys-fishing 305-664-3321
There is no other neighborhood like Anglers Reef in Islamorada
Islamorada has hundreds of Charter Boats available for Fishing Off Shore, In Shore, Snorkeling or sight seeing. Here is contact info for a few of them