'My favorite restaurants and why:
Bayside Gourmet - Locals place (all fresh ingredients): http://baysidegourmet.com/anytime-menu/ 82758 Overseas Hwy My personal Favorite, New Jersey style Italian, Huge portions (split plates) and nice small ambiance, (Eat outside) closed Sunday. Also get your sandwiches “boat wrapped”. They deliver to Anglers Reef at night. NOW SERVING BREAKFAST!
Green Turtle - best breakfast and best conch chowder: http://www.greenturtleinn.com 81219 Overseas Hwy. A lot of History, Great food, kind of pricy, medium casual, Bkfst, Lunch, Dinner good fish preps, great bread pudding. Closed on Monday
Trading Post - Best sandwiches for taking out on the boat, get the lunch pack with chips and cookies. They also sell some of the best aged steaks you've ever had.
Bob's Buns - http://www.bobsbuns.com 81620 Overseas Hwy a Bakery that makes sweet rolls, key lime everything, great cakes and great breakfast, Unique, closes early.
Bud n Mary's-Serves a nice simple eggs and toast and a few other items, convenient for sure if your going on a charter.
Bitton - (French bakery, gelato and breakfast/lunch spot) 82445 Overseas Hwy He is a baker from France who makes the fluffiest, tastiest pastries you ever had, kind of pricey but you are on vacation. Closes after lunch
Hungry Tarpon - http://places.singleplatform.com/hungry-tarpon/menu?ref=google 77522 Overseas Hwy Has great atmosphere Extremely Casual, Feed the Tarpon Good Food, get the trailer trash bloody mary Lunch, Dinner
Key Largo Conch House - (amazing breakfast): http://www.keylargoconchhouse.com/ try the conch omlette and the tropical pancakes (key lime macadamia)
Morada Bay- Great dining on the beach with tiki torches and live music.
Midway Coffee Bar - http://midwaycafecoffeebar.com/menus/ 80499 Overseas Hwy Should be an episode of Tiny Houses! Good coffee, bakery and great nutritious breakfast. Closes at 3pm
Hog Heaven, Sports Bar - with food full bar, late night dancing outdoor seating, walking distance to Anglers 85361 Overseas Hwy.
Mangrove Mikes. -Great breakfast and lunch place portions are huge and always has videos of underwater coral life, GREAT T Shirts, and they are reasonable.
Bumby's - Good Dinner menu, a higher end place, good food 82779 Overseas Hwy. $$$$ has Sunday brunch at 10am. All you can drink bloody mary and mimosa bar for extra $13.
Sundowners - (great for sunset dining): http://www.sundownerskeylargo.com/ awesome lobster bisque
Marker 88 Restaurant - great food, amazing sunsets/atmosphere. Live music. Rocking chair tables.
Café Largo - Great Italian and seafood: http://www.keylargo-cafelargo.com/
Lorelei - Has great Sunsets & music draft and drinks, food is simple, also a place for backcountry charters.
Island Grill - Tuna Nachos!: http://keysislandgrill.com/menu 85501 Overseas Hwy. Popular spot. very close walk to Anglers. Ocean views, Live Music Nightly Lunch Dinner. slow season $3 bloody mary/mimosas with breakfast and has breakfast buffet, but benedicts are really good.
Lazy Days - Get your fish prepared LAZY DAYS STYLE: http://lazydaysrestaurant.com/
Very consistant, great food and excellent water views Lunch Dinner
Chef Michael’s - Fancy gourmet: http://foodtotalkabout.com/ high end amazing food, worth a treat good fish prep SUNDAY BRUNCH
Kaiyo - Sushi and more (best bread pudding ever): http://www.kaiyogrill.com/_index.php Closed Sunday. Try the Macademia roll and the drunken scallops
Islamorada Fish Company - My favorite key lime pie is at Islamorada Fish Company. The nutty crust is different and I really like it. Also has great nightly entertainment.
Zane Grey Bar - Also the Zane Grey Bar upstairs of Worldwide Sportsman, is a great place for a sunset cocktail
Islamorada Fishing Club If you get the opportunity to go to the - GO! It’s a private club with great food and drinks.
Give Jennifer Miller a Call: 305-240-0592
Restaurants
There is no other neighborhood like Anglers Reef in Islamorada